Home Action Alerts Action Alert: Courts, Carbon, and Cool Neighbors
Action Alert: Courts, Carbon, and Cool Neighbors
Friday, 11 December 2009 14:04
  • Environmental groups file case in Wake Superior Court!
  • EPA rules CO2 (from cement plants, among others) endangers human health!
  • Surfrider hangs ten (benjamins) on the Stoptitan wave!

Call it our own Pelican Brief. On Wednesday, December 9, lawyers representing the North Carolina Coastal Federation, Cape Fear Riverwatch, and PenderWatch and Conservancy filed suit in Wake Superior Court, contesting the decision by state agencies to allow Titan Cement to skirt the State Environmental Policy Act of 1971, which states in part:

Every State agency shall include in every recommendation or report on any action involving expenditure of public moneys or use of public land for projects and programs significantly affecting the quality of the environment of this State, a detailed statement by the responsible official setting forth the following:

  • The environmental impact of the proposed action;
  • Any significant adverse environmental effects which cannot be avoided should the proposal be implemented;
  •  Mitigation measures proposed to minimize the impact;
  • Alternatives to the proposed action;
  • The relationship between the short term uses of the environment involved in the proposed action and the maintenance and enhancement of long term productivity; and
  • Any irreversible and irretrievable environmental changes which would be involved in the proposed action should it be implemented.”


As many of you know, SEPA--which would hold all state permits until the federal EIS process is complete-- was required of the Titan project when it was first proposed but was mysteriously removed months later after intensive lobbying by the company. DENR officials contend that since Titan won’t get their $4.2 million of our tax dollars until after the plant is up and polluting—and the damage to our health and environment just beginning--then SEPA doesn’t apply! Yet a time table for public payoffs to companies is nowhere in the Act—and turns the legislation on its head. If that’s all companies have to do to get out of SEPA, then why wouldn’t they all just have their public checks post-dated to avoid a comprehensive environmental review?


Let’s hope the judge has more sense than our DENR officials. Read all about it in the N&O here: http://www.newsobserver.com/politics/state/story/233871.html . And stay tuned for more plot developments.


Also this week, the Environmental Protection Agency declared greenhouse gas emissions—which the coal-burning Titan Cement plant would be a major source—threaten the public health and welfare of the American people. The long-expected ruling comes after a 2007 Supreme Court decision that found carbon dioxide could be regulated under the Clean Air Act. Read all about the new decision here:

http://yosemite.epa.gov/opa/admpress.nsf/d0cf6618525a9efb85257359003fb69d/08d11a451131bca585257685005bf252!OpenDocument

 

The move also comes after a September EPA proposal that would require large industrial facilities like Titan to get construction and operating permits to cover their greenhouse gas emissions. The companies would have to use best available control technologies to minimize GHG emissions when the facility is built. Titan thus far has no controls on its C02 emissions—nor has DAQ required them to. Just one more example of why your local regulators don’t protect you—even when you live in one of the regions of the country most vulnerable to sea level rise from climate change.


Read all about it here:


http://climateprogress.org/2009/09/30/big-breaking-news-new-epa-rule-will-require-use-of-best-technologies-to-reduce-greenhouse-gases-from-large-facilities-when-constructed-or-significantly-modified-small-businesses-and-farms-exe/


And last but certainly not least, early this month our da kine local Surfrider Foundation Cape Fear Chapter donated $1,000 to the StopTitan cause! Mahalo and many thanks to our fellow watermen and women for their generous gift. Like most of the ocean-loving residents of this area, they don’t want to breathe mercury, arsenic, hydrochloric acid, or any other toxic Titan emission when the wind turns light and off-shore from the northwest—straight from Castle Hayne.


And remember, all donations to StopTitan.org/Friends of the Lower Cape Fear are now tax-deductible! So if you’ve got some loose change lying around and want to send it to us instead of Uncle Sam, we’d be delighted to put it to good use in the Titan fight. Just use the quick and easy pay-pal or snail-mail it to the address below.


And as the holidays approach, we’d like to leave you with a few words of inspiration:

The General Assembly of North Carolina, recognizing the profound influence of man's activity on the natural environment, and desiring, in its role as trustee for future generations, to assure that an environment of high quality will be maintained for the health and well being of all, declares that it shall be the continuing policy of the State of North Carolina to conserve and protect its natural resources and to create and maintain conditions under which man and nature can exist in productive harmony. Further, it shall be the policy of the State to seek, for all of its citizens, safe, healthful, productive and aesthetically pleasing surroundings; to attain the widest range of beneficial uses of the environment without degradation, risk to health or safety; and to preserve the important historic and cultural elements of our common inheritance.

(§ 113A 3.  Declaration of State environmental policy.1971, c. 1203, s. 3.)

Happy Holidays from your friends and neighbors at…


StopTitan.org
Friends of the Lower Cape Fear
PO Box 11067
Wilmington NC 28404

 

Comments
Add New Search RSS
Anon   |2010-01-12 17:35:25
The NIMBYism here is awesome.
When it comes down to it Wilmington drivers produce far more CO2 than this plant ever will.
It is you causes your child's asthma, their cancer, not Titan Cement.
You could easily offset the amount of CO2 that the Titan plant would produce by carpooling to work. Will you? No.
As for me I'm more worried about one of you idiots hitting me with your 4-wheeled monstrosities while I'm biking to class.
Take some responsibility for your own actions, because like it or not they impact the rest of us.
Ian Oeschger   |2010-01-12 17:50:53
If only CO2 were the only issue, Anon.

And I don't get the belligerent tone: Do you want a new cement plant here? What is it that you're supporting?

Are you just having fun trolling sites of groups whose overall politics you don't support? Seems like it (viz: "idiots", "take responsibility", presuming to know what "kind of people" oppose Titan.)
Anon   |2010-01-13 09:45:37
This story was focused on CO2 emissions.

Hence, why I neglected to mention other types of emissions.

The belligerent tone comes from annoyance stemming from the failure of Wilmington to have a strong public transportation system, the almost non-existence of a robust cycling infrastructure (Not to mention the aggressive attitude of some Wilmington drivers toward cyclists).
As Wilmington is a city with relatively little urban sprawl, perhaps due to our geographical location, it would be easy for most people to commute via bicycle. Though some times this is not possible for a variety of reasons(Transporting multiple small children, being overweight to the point that a bike cannot support your weight?).

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2008/apr/15/health
Study done in the UK finding a strong correlation between pollution by cars and deaths caused by pneumonia. Findings probably hold true for the US as well.

http://www.epa.gov/otaq/consumer/f00013.htm
Information about vehicle emissions from the EPA

To answer your question "Do you want a new cement plant here? What is it you're supporting?" I do not wish to have a new cement plant built. The problem I have is that popular support is being built to block the Titan plant from being built but at the same time so much more could be done to reduce air pollution in Wilmington and nation wide.

(http://www.cityryde.com/blog/which-north-american-cities-are-publicly-looking-into-bike-sharing/
This site claims that a bike share program could happen in Wilmington, a step in the right direction.)
Ian Oeschger   |2010-01-13 11:51:39
Anon, I could not agree more about biking and this area. Thanks for clarifying.

I'm really hoping that the gettingconnected.org folks will take their mission big in this area, become a consolidation voice for bicycling.

Alexander   |2010-01-14 19:31:18
Anon,
Welcome to Stop Titan. Many people have no real idea exactly how big the Titan America plant will be and how much toxic waste will be emitted from the stack - not only for one year but for the projected 30 - 50 year life span of the operation.

Not your fault. Titan makes every effort to shield these facts from the general public and refuses to answer direct questions in open, public forums even though Titan promised the citizens of New Hanover County to do just that only minutes before they accepted our ill advised $4.2 million incentive package.

The pertinent facts for your question above: The Titan America cement plant in Castle Hayne will emit 2.4 million tons of CO2 per year. The average midsize car averaging 21 miles/gas and driving 12,500 miles per year emits 6 tons of CO2 per year (US EPA). This means that the Titan America plant will emit in one year the same amount of CO2 as approximately 400,000 cars with each car driving 12,500 miles. In round figures there are 177,000 registered in New Hanover County with compatible emissions so the single Titan smoke stack will emit more than twice the amount of CO2 generated by all the cars in New Hanover County every year.

The sad fact is that as citizens in New Hanover County move into high milage/hybrid/low emission cars over the next few decades we will still be stuck with Titan and it's out dated polluting stack in Castle Hayne.


kelly stryker   |2010-01-15 06:41:49
We're all on the same team here. All want the same important changes in our community...reducing air pollution, more bike access, more public transport, less heavy-polluting industries like Titan cement and their mine. A progressive vision for future development and economic growth....but instead of being frustrated at the lack of progress on various important issues, we ALL need to work TOGETHER. Step one: elect better local officials, esp. on the NH County Commissioner seat. You can pretty much trace every bad decision (Titan, approving our newest school beside a contaminated waste site, no support for development fees that would help offset community costs for sidewalks, bike trails, etc.) that we're all ticked off about to the old-boys club that continues to dominate our public policy and public will. Wilmington Industrial Development should not be the only economic engine in town, they're the only one our CC's listen to. The newly formed group, CFEDC have visions more consistent with our community, but we're at a cross roads. We need a HUGE infusion of progressive, smart, innovate folks who listen and think. Not parceling out between Dems or Republicans, but people who can stay awake past eight o'clock, are willing to listen, and have a better pulse on the community. Nothing is going to change unless our local officials change. So all you folks blogging and complaining....take a run for a local office. Cuz you'd have to be better than the current lot!
lisa b   |2010-01-21 09:09:35
Hi Kelly
I would love to run for a local office :) Would love to come down to Wilmington and discuss with you the latest on Titan? Have forwarded this last e-mail to many in the Raleigh area. This group CFEDC is located where? lisa b
kelly stryker   |2010-01-23 17:08:54
Hi Lisa B,

The group is called Cape Fear Economic Development Council. Chocked full of forward-thinking local business leaders, this new group aims to focus on economic development that is low impact and high tech. An important and new voice that will only make the case against Titan and similar heavy polluting industries stronger and reiterate that we can do better. The website is http://capefearedc.org/
kelly stryker   |2010-01-23 17:13:24
Oh, and please do come here. Our StopTitan group all live and work here, all highly motivated to be part of the change for our area. Pls. email our site or call our 800 number if you'd like more info. (and if you come, can you bring some clean jobs with you???)
cementman  - cementman     |2010-02-01 20:19:41
You silly tre huggers need to get a grip!!! I don't see none of ya'll crying when Wilmington dumps 500,000 gallons of raw sewage in tha river or the power plants in the area(that keep your freakin lights on) burn coal!This area needs JOBS!!! So when ya get layed off or told your sevices are no longer needed...DON'T BOTHER APPLYING AT TITAN WE KNOW WHO YOU ARE!!!!
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."